In late September, Graziano and Maurizio Ricci threw a goodbye party at 222 Hillspoint Road. According to 06880, dozens of friends and customers came from the neighborhood and farther away, and the brothers covered the food and drinks. Then Romanacci's handed back the keys to Old Mill Grocery & Deli after three years.
The Riccis "enjoyed their time, and did not lose money," 06880 reported, and they are opening a new restaurant in Darien. Ian Warburg, co-founder of the nonprofit that owns the building, gave the Westport Journal a blunter version. "They made money," he said. "It was a profitable operation, not wildly profitable and not sufficient to keep their attention when they have other much more profitable activities to engage in and pursue."
Old Mill is a beach-season business that turns a modest profit, and a modest profit has not kept an operator past a few years. Both the hunt for a new tenant and the zoning proposal going back before the Planning and Zoning Commission on Monday, November 2, try to fix that same weakness. The proposal could also reach two other neighborhood food shops in residential parts of town.
A Market the Neighbors Already Saved Once
Old Mill has been selling food at that corner since 1919. Its current ownership goes back to a rescue. CTBites reported that longtime owners Hal and Betsy Kravitz left Westport and had trouble finding a buyer. Neighborhood residents Jim Hood, Ian Warburg and Chris Tait then formed Soundview Empowerment Alliance, and community donations plus a GoFundMe raised more than $1.5 million to save the building. CT Insider dates SEA's formation to late December 2021.
The operators who have run the store since then:
- July 2022. TGB Hospitality Group, the parent company of The Granola Bar, reopened Old Mill as a market and deli selling groceries, prepared food and coffee, 06880 reported.
- The next three years. Romanacci's served coffee, baked goods, quiches and breakfast sandwiches in the morning, then Italian-style sandwiches, appetizers and Roman-style pizza.
- Fall 2026. Closed, with no new operator named as of 06880's October 20 report.
Two operators in about four years is the pattern Eric Bernheim, SEA's attorney, has in mind. He told P&Z on October 19 that he hopes "we'll have longevity instead of change every 2 or 3 years as the operators get worn down."
Summer Carries the Store, Winter Decides Who Stays
Warburg was direct with the Westport Journal about what a lasting tenant needs. "The viable future is an operator who comes in with a really site-specific plan and concept that's less seasonal in nature, more year-round in offering," he said. The paper noted that Old Mill has long done well in summer because it sits so close to the beach. Warburg said the store's history shows a year-round business can work: "It just takes putting together the right combination of offerings and marketing it well to the community." He said Romanacci's did "a really great job" but could not get past the seasonal swing.
There are candidates. In mid-September SEA was in "active discussions with no fewer than four very capable and experienced groups," Warburg said, and one of them "wants to start like tomorrow." He also said the bidders "absolutely believe they've got ideas that will not only address the high season but that will carry the business through the winter months and provide real value to the neighborhood." SEA plans to review every proposal before choosing.
Each of those proposals depends on what the building is allowed to sell.
The Rulebook Behind the Menu
Old Mill is a commercial business in a residential zone. As the Westport Journal explains, the store doesn't conform to the zoning for its location.
In November 2024, the town tried to allow alcohol sales and drinks at outdoor tables with text amendments. A group of neighbors sued, citing parking, traffic, noise and pedestrian safety. On February 18, 2026, Superior Court Judge Dale W. Radcliffe overturned the amendments, finding that they improperly expanded a nonconforming commercial use in a residential zone.
The owners are now pursuing two routes at once. The Appellate Court has agreed to review Radcliffe's ruling, and Bernheim expects that review to take more than a year. While that case is pending, SEA has filed a new proposal. The town's notice describes Text Amendment #875, which would create a Food and Beverage Planned Development District covering grocery stores, delis, retail food establishments, restaurants, cafes and taverns. It would also set standards for outdoor eating areas and for on-premises alcohol sales at retail food establishments. Map Amendment #876 would rezone 222 Hillspoint Road from Residence B into the new district. 06880 reported that the outdoor eating areas would have to be within 25 feet of the main building.
Warburg told the Westport Journal that SEA is open to a BYOB component, depending on what is proposed and permitted.
Two Other Counters in the Same Position
The new district would be a "floating" one, and P&Z would decide which lots go into it. Bernheim mentioned two other food shops in residential areas that could eventually be included.
| Shop | Address | What's on the counter | Where it stands |
|---|---|---|---|
| Old Mill Grocery & Deli | 222 Hillspoint Road | Market and deli since 1919 | Closed, operator search underway |
| Gruel Britannia | 161 Cross Highway | Fish and chips, bangers and mash, shepherd's pie, afternoon tea, plus a grab-and-go Tuck Shop | Open since July 2025 |
| The Country Store | 332 Wilton Road | Breakfast sandwiches, deli sandwiches, Reubens, tuna melts, burgers, hot dogs | Open |
Gruel Britannia is the newest. Karen Hubrich and Scott Rochlin opened it in July 2025 in the space that used to be the Porch at Christie's, according to the Westport Journal. The Country Store on Wilton Road runs a short-order menu built around breakfast and deli sandwiches.
So the vote is about more than one beach market. It asks whether Westport wants one set of rules for the old neighborhood food counters scattered through its residential streets, and P&Z would decide how many of them that rulebook covers.
Where Each Side Stands Going Into November 2
When P&Z took up the proposal on October 19, chair Paul Lebowitz called the text amendment very supportable. "This is exactly what is needed to save a jewel of Westport," he said, as reported by 06880. RTM member Jimmy Izzo spoke in favor: "The community really loves it, and it's a not a crazy place." The Westport Journal quoted RTM member Chris Tait, one of SEA's founders: "What we're looking for is to keep this gem alive. And we're not trying to make it any more than that."
The Old Mill Preservation Group, a group of residents who oppose alcohol sales at the store, is still against it. Its attorney told the commission he expects the courts to reject the new regulation as well, and he argued that the town has not studied what the change would do. The neighbors' original concerns about parking, traffic, noise and pedestrian safety in the neighborhood are part of the public record in this case.
The commission voted to continue the discussion at its November 2 meeting. The town calendar lists that meeting for 6 p.m., held electronically. For the October hearing, the town streamed the meeting on its website and on Optimum Government Access Channel 79. It posted the Zoom link with the agenda on its Meeting List and Calendar page and took written comments at [email protected] until noon on the day of the meeting. Application materials are on the P&Z department's Pending Applications and Recent Approvals page.
Whatever P&Z decides, SEA still has to pick a tenant. In its report on the September goodbye, 06880 wrote that the owners hoped for "a fairly quick reopening." Until a new operator is announced, the communal table that 06880 called a community gathering place stays empty, while Gruel Britannia on Cross Highway and the Country Store on Wilton Road stay open.
As a sixth-generation Fairfield County local, Libby knows how much a landmark like Old Mill means to the street around it. If you own near Compo, Old Mill Beach or Hillspoint Road and want to know how neighborhood changes like this one affect your home's position, On The Harbor can help. Request a private home valuation.